Marc A. Nelson, Jr.: "A Jack Stone pirate set in New Gray and Chocolate Brown... Redbeard must be rolling in his watery grave."
Eric Hampusgård: "O julklapp 04"
Ben Medinets: "at best, a poorly designed pirate ship with ugly poop pieces"
Jon Furman: "Yuck"
Arne Nielsen: "Hull 20 studs wide. Only 3 hull pieces, so you would need 2 sets to make a prolonged, decent looking merchant vessel. Railing pieces are big POOPs, and the rest are just awful! 2nd set included motor"
Richie Dulin: "It's no Black Seas Barracuda, but there is plenty of potential in this set. The hull is big and wide, and some of the other bits are quite good too. At $A50 it's a great buy."
Andy Lowe: "I'm not going to lie to you... it doesn't look good."