Ben Medinets: "Jack Sparrow, Blackbeard, and a pegleg Barbarossa"
Mark Chittenden: "Only set with Admiral Barbossa"
Philip Moyer: "Fountain doesn't look at all like the one in the movie, but they had to make do. Has nice trans-blue pieces, though, and the ribbed cylinder bricks. Though the upward waterfall arch hints at it."
Peter Smith: "Not bad, but the prices for the whole line are atrocious. This really needed a 16 x 16 baseplate, too."
Jeff Block: "Neat transfparent pieces; "flexible" waterfall makes for good playability but bad LEGO...Blackbeard's cutlass is pretty cool"
Michael A. Joosten: "Great parts pack--dark tan 2x4s, lots of dark green, and pillar pieces--the Barbossa fig is also really excellent. Blackbeard's sword is... a bit overdone, but a rare new pirates sword."